SCUBA Rebreather:
An In-Depth Guide to Their Use, Benefits, and Risks
​
SCUBA has advanced significantly over the recent years, with one of the biggest advancements in dive technology being the development of rebreathers. These sophisticated devices have been complete game changers in both recreational and professional diving, offering several benefits over traditional open-circuit SCUBA systems. However, as with any advanced technology, rebreathers come with their own set of challenges, including potential risks, specialized training, and maintenance requirements. In this article, we will dive into what SCUBA rebreathers are, how they work, their advantages and disadvantages, and the best options on the market.
​
What is a SCUBA Rebreather?
A SCUBA rebreather is a closed or semi-closed circuit breathing device that allows divers to reuse exhaled gas. Unlike traditional open-circuit SCUBA systems, where the diver exhales air into the water around them, rebreathers capture the diver's exhaled breath and recycle it, adding small bursts of oxygen to the mix as needed. This leads to more efficient use of the breathing gas, which can extend dive time, reduce gas consumption, and minimize the environmental impact of diving.
​
A rebreather system allows the diver to breathe a mixture of gases (such as oxygen and nitrox) that is custom-fitted to the dive’s depth and duration. The system scrubs carbon dioxide (CO2) from the exhaled breath, ensuring the diver receives a fresh supply of breathable air without the need to constantly inhale new gas from tanks.
There are two main types of SCUBA rebreathers:
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
1.) Closed-circuit rebreathers (CCR) – These rebreathers maintain a constant supply of breathable gas, adjusting the oxygen content based on depth and the diver's metabolic rate. CO2 is removed using a scrubber, and excess oxygen is added to keep the system balanced.
​​
2.) Semi-closed circuit rebreathers (SCR) – These systems allow a portion of exhaled gas to escape, while the remaining gas is recycled. SCR systems are simpler and more affordable than CCR systems but are less efficient.
​​
How Do SCUBA Rebreathers Work?
The basic function of a rebreather revolves around three key processes:
​
1.) Inhalation: The diver inhales a gas mixture from the rebreather loop. This mixture typically includes oxygen, nitrogen, and sometimes helium, depending on the dive profile.
​​
2.) Exhalation and CO2 Scrubbing: After exhaling, the gas passes through a scrubber (a canister filled with a chemical absorbent, typically soda lime or similar substances) that removes carbon dioxide. The remaining gas is then recirculated in the system.
​​
3.) Oxygen Addition: As the gas is recirculated, the system constantly monitors the oxygen partial pressure and adds oxygen as needed, using an injector or solenoid valve. This is done to ensure that the diver always breathes a mixture with the correct oxygen content for the dive's depth.
​​
The rebreather allows for the gas mixture to be customized based on depth, dive time, and other factors. The addition of oxygen at specific intervals, the removal of CO2, and the control over nitrogen absorption make rebreathers ideal for deep dives or long-duration dives where a standard SCUBA tank might be inefficient.
​
Benefits of SCUBA Rebreathers
​
1. Extended Dive Time
Rebreathers allow divers to stay underwater much longer than with traditional open-circuit SCUBA systems. Since the diver is recycling the gas, there is less wastage, and the same volume of gas can be used for longer periods. This is particularly beneficial for deep or technical dives, where gas consumption is a major limiting factor.
​
2. Reduced Gas Consumption
In a traditional open-circuit system, the diver exhales a significant amount of gas with each breath. A rebreather recycles this gas, removing CO2 and adding fresh oxygen as needed, resulting in reduced gas consumption. This not only extends dive times but also reduces the number of gas cylinders needed for longer dives.
​
3. Silent Operation
Since rebreathers do not expel bubbles like open-circuit systems, they offer a quieter, more discreet diving experience. This is particularly valuable for underwater photography, cave diving, or military and research operations where noise reduction is important.
​
4. Decreased Environmental Impact
With rebreathers, the diver uses less gas, which can lead to less environmental disruption, especially in sensitive underwater ecosystems. Moreover, the elimination of bubbles reduces the physical disturbance to marine life, allowing for closer, more intimate interactions with underwater fauna.
​
5. More Control Over Gas Mix
Rebreathers give divers precise control over their breathing gas, allowing for adjustments in real-time based on depth, metabolic needs, and the specific demands of the dive. This flexibility is essential for divers operating in extreme conditions, such as deep dives or dives in remote locations.
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​​
​
​
​
​
​
Disadvantages of SCUBA Rebreathers
​
1. Complexity and Cost
Rebreathers are significantly more complex than open-circuit systems. They require sophisticated electronics, sensors, and valves to monitor gas mixes and ensure the diver’s safety. The systems can be expensive to purchase, maintain, and repair, making them less accessible for recreational divers. However, Encounter SCUBA is meeting this need by offering financing at an affordable rate through Affirm! Apply today without harming your credit score!
​
​
2. Increased Training Requirements
Due to their complexity and the potential risks involved, rebreather divers must undergo specialized training. This training is critical to ensure divers can properly manage the system, troubleshoot issues, and respond to emergencies. Without proper training, rebreathers can be dangerous.
​
3. Risk of Oxygen Toxicity
If the oxygen partial pressure in the rebreather system is not carefully managed, there is a risk of oxygen toxicity, which can lead to seizures or other health issues. The diver must continuously monitor their oxygen levels and make adjustments as needed, especially during deep dives.
​
4. Potential for Malfunction
Although these occurrences are not common; rebreathers can malfunction, and the diver needs to be prepared for such situations. Malfunctions can occur with oxygen sensors, scrubbers, or other components, and if not addressed immediately, these issues could lead to a life-threatening situation. Training for proper equipment care and use is imperative for these amazing machines, and divers will be masters of their machine by the end of the entry-level tech course.
​
Training
​​​
What is the best rebreather on the market?
The Hollis Prism 2 rebreather is the best rebreather on the market by far for many reasons. Here are a few of the things that set it apart from the competition:
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
1.) Reliability
The Prism 2 was designed by technical divers for technical divers, with the harsh elements of technical diving in mind. Every piece of this machine is equipped with failsafes and backups to ensure safe operation on deep exploration dives in the harshest environments. The P2 is known throughout the technical diving community as the toughest unit on the market and continues to prove itself as the top product year after year.
​
2.) Comfort
Independent third-party testing has confirmed that the P2 boasts the lowest work of breathing on the market by far. Weighing in at 1.7 J/L at forty feet of seawater with air as a diluent, making it easier to breathe than any other rebreather out there. It also features an adjustable harness system with shoulder pads designed for comfort and function.
​
3.) Customer Service
It is very important to choose a rebreather that can be supported with service and consumables. Encounter SCUBA has a certified Hollis rebreather technician on staff to handle your annual maintenance and everything you need to keep it running like clockwork. Every Prism 2 rebreather comes with a 2-year warranty when purchased new from an authorized dealer.
​
Conclusion
SCUBA rebreathers represent a major leap forward in diving technology, offering divers the ability to extend their time underwater, reduce their gas consumption, and experience a quieter and more controlled dive. However, their complexity, higher costs, and potential risks—especially when it comes to gas toxicity and equipment malfunctions—make them a choice best suited to experienced and well-trained divers.
​
As with all diving technologies, safety is paramount. With proper knowledge, preparation, and respect for the equipment, SCUBA rebreathers can significantly enhance the diving experience, opening up new possibilities for exploration and adventure in the underwater world.
​
Feel free to reach out via email, or phone for more info on rebreather diving, training, or personal stories and advice.
​
Email: encounterscuba@gmail.com
​
More info:
​
